Showing posts with label [vova-maltsev]. Show all posts
Showing posts with label [vova-maltsev]. Show all posts

Russia: The "Big White Circle" Protest in Moscow

Global Voices Online
Monday, February 27, 2012


This post is part of our special coverage Russia Elections 2011/12.

On Sunday, Feb. 26, thousands of people gathered in central Moscow for the Big White Circle protest, forming a human chain along most of the length of the Russian capital's 15.6-kilometer/9.7-mile Garden Ring, protesting against corruption and demanding a fair presidential election, which is to take place in one week, on March 4.


The Big White Circle protest for fair election: people stood along the Garden Ring in Moscow, holding hands and waving white ribbons, flowers and balloons. Photo by MARIA PLESHKOVA, copyright © Demotix (26/02/12).

According to the Q&A note [ru] posted on the Facebook page [ru] devoted to the protests in Moscow, the idea of the Big White Circle does not have a specific author:

[...] The idea is on the surface: hundreds of groups of people were doing this in the 20th century when they wanted to show solidarity with each other regarding certain issues. The best-known action of this kind is [the Baltic Way] of 1989, similar actions took place in Moscow in the late 1980s, and this is being done in Europe nowadays. [...]

In the same Q&A note, there is an explanation of why one of the protest's slogans - "Let's encircle the Kremlin" - shouldn't be taken literally:

[...] We can now be sure that if we choose to surround the Kremlin on Feb. 26, we'll definitely have detentions, beatings, arrests and trials. [...] Are you sure that we have 5,000-6,000 people who are prepared to be jailed for participating in this story? We are not sure [...]. [...] Some of us are probably prepared to play the game of "a 70% chance of getting [a 5-year sentence]" - but this, of course, is a game for heroically courageous people. Our courage, just like yours, has its limits. We respect those who are prepared for such a self-sacrifice. And we also respect those who aren't prepared for that. [...]

There's been no lack of international media reports on the Big White Circle protest. One post on the Moscow protests Facebook page reads [ru, en]:

The whole world has learned about the White Circle! Here are some of the headlines from the world's leading news agencies and mass media: Thousands join human chain protest against Putin || Anti-Putin protesters form 'ring around Moscow' || Impressive anti-Putin demonstration in Moscow || Moscow's Big White Circle || Nine mile human chain encircles Moscow in anti Vladimir-Putin protest || Moscow surrounded: Holding hands 'for fair elections' || Muscovites link hands to protest Putin's grip on power || Putin protests cause a 'chain reaction'...

In a comment to this post, Ekaterina Vizgalova wrote [ru]:

The whole world has noticed, while the [state-owned] Channel One hasn't.

RIA Novosti, a state-owned Russian news agency, did notice the Big White Circle protest, however, producing this fast-motion video of a car ride around the Garden Ring at the time of the protest:



A popular Russian blogger Roustem Adagamov (LJ user drugoi) also took a ride around the Garden Ring, pausing to take photos. He wrote this [ru] in the intro to his photo report:

A few tens of thousands of Muscovites have gathered at the Garden Ring today, to take part in the Big White Circle civic action. I rode all around the Garden Ring in an hour and a half, with brief stops - it all looked very cool and fun. The way it always does at genuine gatherings of free citizens who come there of their own free will and not on the orders from their bosses. Cars with white [symbols of the protest] were riding along the [Garden Ring], honking, and people were waving white ribbons, flowers, and balloons. An excellent action, very upbeat and cheerful. [...]


The Big White Circle protest. Photo by MARIA PLESHKOVA, copyright © Demotix (26/02/12).

Another popular blogger, Oleg Kozyrev (LJ user oleg-kozyrev/@oleg_kozyrev), also drove around the Garden Ring, taking photos and shooting a video (which he hasn't posted yet). Following this ride, Kozyrev tweeted [ru] that initially he had doubted that the Big White Circle protest would succeed:

Now I'll confess that I didn't expect success and was feeling pessimistic :)

In the intro to his photo report - a "photo-circle" - Kozyrev wrote [ru]:

[...] A white circle, a live circle. It is becoming more and more obvious that the angry [PM Vladimir Putin] has already lost. He can no longer stop this avalanche of positive resistance.

Will the smile be able to stop the rough force? This is what we'll have to find out in the coming days. [...]


The Big White Circle protest. Photo by MARIA PLESHKOVA, copyright © Demotix (26/02/12).

"Moscow in the circle of friends" is the title of LJ user vova-maltsev's photo report from the Feb. 26 protest. He wrote [ru]:

Some people were saying that we wouldn't be able to close the circle around the Garden Ring. Aha... We have closed it, in two rows. The first one - with the pedestrians, the second - with the drivers.

If you want to see what people who love their country and wish it well look like, here [they are]. [...] I haven't seen so many kind, happy and smiling people in a very long time. At the [regular] rallies, everyone are piled together, while here you are walking down the street and enjoying it. [...]


The Big White Circle protest. Photo by MARIA PLESHKOVA, copyright © Demotix (26/02/12).

More photo reports can be found in the live_report LJ community (by LJ users tushinetc and semasongs), as well as in the namarsh-ru LJ community (by LJ user belial_68).

The next opposition rally is planned for March 5, the day after the election. Moscow city authorities, however, have rejected the opposition's request to hold the rally on Lubyanka Square.

Serguei Parkhomenko, one of the most active participants of the protest movement, wrote this [ru] on Facebook about the significance of the Big White Circle protest - and the wider meaning of March 5 for Russia:

[...] I think we all understand that our today's initiative is not only the last and very powerful event in the history of the past three months [...]. It is also the beginning of a new stage, a new long and difficult conversation that we will all have to be engaged in. Much patience, resilience and strength will be needed. [...]

[...]

We need to avoid making a mistake as we search for the right decision for March 5. [...] History is again offering us a strange and powerful rhyme. It is hinting on something important.

March 5 is the anniversary of the day on which the country got rid of one tyrant [the day on which Joseph Stalin died in 1953]. [...]

March 5 isn't just a random day for all of us.

This post is part of our special coverage Russia Elections 2011/12.

Russia: Bloggers' Photo Reports and Reflections on Pro-Putin Rally in Moscow

Global Voices Online
Saturday, February 25, 2012


This post is part of our special coverage Russia Elections 2011/12.

On Thursday, Feb. 23, ten days before the March 4 presidential election, the Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin addressed thousands of people at the Luzhniki Stadium in Moscow. The Guardian's Miriam Elder described the event as "a gathering reminiscent of Soviet spectacle both in rhetoric and style":

[...] Thousands of workers from the provinces were bussed in or rushed on to trains to attend the event. [...]


A rally in support of PM Vladimir Putin took place in Moscow on Feb. 23, ahead of the presidential election on March 4. Photo by Irina Firsova, copyright © Demotix (23/02/12).

A number of Moscow-based bloggers attended the Feb. 23 rally, too. Below is a selection of their photo reports and observations, along with some of the remarks from their audiences.

LJ user mi3ch posted 17 photos and wrote [ru]:

Absolutely ordinary people. Trusting. Good. Like my aunt. Like my next-door neighbor. Students, workers, [state employees], pensioners. Seven out of ten - women. Mothers and grandmothers. And they really like Putin. He is so brave and decisive. [...]

Their main distinction from [those who attended the opposition's rallies at Bolotnaya Square] are their faces. At Luzhniki, hardly anyone was smiling. And almost everyone walked silently. [...]

LJ user otshellnica rebuked the blogger [ru] in the comments section:

At Bolotnaya, you could find the same [unsmiling] faces in the multi-thousand crowd. Just as there were nice and smiling faces at this rally. You, of all people, shouldn't be playing with such cheap arguments.

LJ user maxsytch offered [ru] a different point of comparison between the anti- and pro-Putin rallies:

The difference was in the percentage of the people who came to Bolotnaya and Luzhniki voluntarily.

Ryazan-based LJ user tamrat elaborated [ru] on the definition of 'voluntarily,' citing her city's participation in the Feb. 23 rally as an example:

People from Ryazan enterprises came voluntarily - and joyfully. And whether they are for Putin or not is irrelevant. They had a tour of Moscow for free! They were taken there, got fed, listened to a concert. And all this for free! People came back home happy. And nothing will change in our country until a person can be made happy with free food and a trip!

LJ user vova-maltsev posted 14 photos [ru] and recounted his quick conversations with some of the rally's participants:

[...]

- Why are you here?
- We've been brought in here, [damn it].
- Are you for Putin?
- [Screw him], our salary's 17,000 [rubles a month, $580].

[...]

There were [Tajik migrant workers] sitting in one of the buses.
- Are you for Putin?
- [We work as cleaners in Izmailovo, damn it, and we are stuck here now. Will have to do our job all night.]

[...]

Nice [female] school cooks.
- What are you doing here?
- We've been dispatched here.
- To cook porridge [for the rally's participants]?
- Yes.
- Did you go to Bolotnaya?
- No, they didn't send us there.
- Are you for Putin?
- Yes, of course... Are you a journalist?
- Yes. I'm not for Putin.
- (whispering) We are all against him. All our teachers are against, too.

An anonymous reader left this comment [ru] to LJ user vova-maltsev's post:

[They are being drawn there forcefully.] They aren't even getting paid, the motivation is their fear of problems at work + 1 day off. This info is 100% true. Relatives work at a state enterprise, in Moscow.

LJ user panzicov (Alexei Vitvitskiy) posted 48 photos [ru] on his blog. Five of these photos, the blogger claims, show a group of people allegedly being paid for their participation in the rally:

[...] The conscience of the people costs 800 rubles [$27] for two hours, [the money] was being handed out at [Park Kultury metro station] right after the rally. [...]

Seven photos in LJ user panzicov's report show a group of young black men carrying handmade banners with pro-Putin slogans on them. Another blogger, LJ user drandin (Igor Drandin), talked with these men, asking them where they were from, and posted the video [ru, en] on his blog and on YouTube; one of the men explained, in English, that they were from Kenya.

LJ user pier_luigi, commenting on LJ user panzicov's post, wrote this [ru] about Putin's Kenyan supporters:

North Korea this is not - not yet... But the representatives of international Putinism are very impressive!

LJ user tushinetc posted 16 photos [ru] taken before most of the rally's participants took their seats at the Luzhniki Stadium. One of the photos shows empty seats with identical plastic bags on them. LJ user tushinetc explained:

[...] Some organizations took good care of their employees, making sure they do not get cold while sitting on plastic [seats]. In each bag placed on the seats there's a blanket, as well as a candy and a tangerine, and on the seat itself, there's [a cloth mat for sitting]. [...]

LJ user 2014imeretinka commented [ru]:

How mean! For a candy and a tangerine...

LJ user panfilosoff replied [ru]:

Not mean at all... If you don't attend, you'll have serious problems at work, and if you do attend, you'll get a reward and a tangerine. Everything's simple and logical.

This post is part of our special coverage Russia Elections 2011/12.